Hot Cross Bun & Butter Pudding

Difficulty - Medium
Prep time - 15 minutes
Cook time - 30 minutes
Serves - 4-6

Hot Cross Bun & Butter Pudding

A simple twist on the traditional bread and butter pudding. Perfect for Easter, Hot Cross Buns spread with butter, soaked and baked in a creamy custard. This recipe is a great way to use leftover Hot Cross Buns, if you can resist keeping some aside!

Tips with Butter

Mix up some rosemary and HP sauce with Westgold Butter, roll it into a log using greaseproof paper, and freeze to create a “ready-to-eat” steak sauce.


50g Westgold butter
4-5 hot cross buns (depending on how big your baking dish is)
3 beaten eggs (eggs at room temperature work best)
1 cup cream
1 cup milk
1 vanilla pod
1/3 cup white sugar
extra butter for greasing
raw sugar for sprinkling


Preheat the oven to 170 deg. 

Place milk, cream, white sugar and halved/scraped vanilla bean in a saucepan and heat until sugar dissolves. Take off the heat and leave until cool to give the vanilla bean time to infuse.  Remove the vanilla bean stir in the eggs.

Grease a 20cm x 30cm oven proof dish with butter. Slice the hot cross buns into 5 slices each (like you would slice a loaf of bread) and butter one side of each slice. Arrange in the greased dish, spreading them out slightly, but with the slices still resting on each other. See cooking image below.

Pour over the egg custard mixture, using a knife to lift the slices to make sure the custard has soaked in between the slices.  Dice the butter and dot over the top and sprinkle with raw sugar. 

Bake on top shelf of the oven for 30 minutes. Check in the middle of the pudding to make sure it is ready by looking in between a slice to make sure the egg custard has set.  It should feel spongy when pressed with your finger.

Serve immediately with vanilla ice cream or custard.

Hot Cross Bun Butter Pudding butter

Back to
recipe search